Western Sydney Wanderers — Melbourne City : Match Preview and Prediction for October 18,2025

Wanderers’ Troubled Start

Starting with the home side, the Wanderers approach the opening round following a deeply concerning incident in August. Their last official fixture saw them crash out of the Australia Cup, suffering a humiliating 0-3 defeat to Heidelberg United. Despite boasting 69% possession, this proved to be sterile dominance, yielding a mere 0.91 xG. In stark contrast, their opponents, with half the possession, generated 1.90 xG worth of chances, forcing goalkeeper Lawrence Thomas into six crucial saves.

Key Departures and Attacking Void

The off-season has brought a significant blow to the club. Not merely a skilled player, but the recipient of the Johnny Warren Medal as last season’s A-League Player of the Year, Nicolas Milanovic, has departed. He was undeniably the engine and creative force behind the Wanderers’ attacks. His exit, coupled with the promising forward Zach Sapsford also leaving, creates a massive void in their offensive capabilities, one that the newly arrived Angus Thurgate, despite his qualities, is ill-equipped to fill due to his different playing style.

Internal Discord and Pre-Season Woes

Adding to their concerns are media reports suggesting strained relations between coach Alen Stajcic and the club’s management. A lack of internal unity almost always translates into on-field struggles. The Wanderers enter this season as a team searching for a new identity, having lost crucial personnel and potentially their internal cohesion. This is hardly an ideal foundation from which to face the reigning champions.

Champions’ Strong Start

The reigning champions, however, approach the season’s commencement in a vastly different state. Melbourne City’s primary advantage is their current battle-ready status. While the Wanderers were navigating their pre-season, Aurelio Vidmar’s squad had already contended with two arduous Asian Champions League fixtures. Matches against Japan’s Vissel Kobe and Sanfrecce Hiroshima offer an entirely distinct level of intensity and a hardening experience that no friendly match can replicate.

Key Returns and Boosted Morale

Coach Vidmar was unequivocal in his press conference, stating: “We are here to claim the title once more.” Crucially, key midfield players Mathew Leckie and Andreas Kuen are set to return to action for the opening round.

New Additions and Readiness

Team captain and defender Aziz Behich has just been honored with the PFA Australian Player of the Year award. New signings Takeshi Kanamori and Elbasan Rashani have already seen action in the AFC Champions League and are primed for their league debuts. Melbourne City has clearly hit its stride and is fully prepared to defend its title.